Easy MobX and Redux Comparison

published Mar 13, 2018

In this article/video we'll start with a simple React app made with create-react-app that uses component state (setState) as its state management. We'll then take it from component state to MobX, and then again from component state to Redux. During the process we'll see what is similar and different between the two approaches.

The code we are looking at is asynchronous, so we'll see how each library handles async code differently.

The repository lives at https://github.com/leighhalliday/easy-mobx-redux-comparison and contains 3 branches:

  • master: The component state version
  • mobx: The MobX version
  • redux: The Redux version

Component State to MobX

MobX data flow diagaram

In MobX our data lives in a Store, which has at its easiest, observable properties and action functions which can modify the store's values.

import { observable, action, runInAction } from "mobx";
import axios from "axios";

default class GalleryStore {
@observable term = "";
@observable images = [];
@observable status = "initial";

@action
fetchImages = async term => {
this.status = "searching";
this.term = term;
this.images = [];

try {
const response = await axios.get(
"https://api.unsplash.com/search/photos",
{
params: {
client_id: "abcdef",
query: term
}
}
);
this.setImages(response.data.results);
} catch (error) {
runInAction(() => {
this.status = "error";
});
}
};

@action
setImages = images => {
this.images = images;
this.status = "done";
};
}

We gain the ability to inject our store into our components and make them act as observer's to the changes in the store, by wrapping a Provider component around our top level component.

import { Provider } from "mobx-react";

import GalleryStore from "./stores/GalleryStore";
const galleryStore = new GalleryStore();

ReactDOM.render(
<Provider galleryStore={galleryStore}>
<App />
</Provider>,
document.getElementById("root")
);

Inject MobX into React

Now we can inject the store into our component, which will pass our whole store as a prop which in this case is called galleryStore (defined in the Provider).

import { inject, observer } from "mobx-react";

@inject("galleryStore")
@observer
default class App extends React.Component {
// render, componentDidMount, etc...
}

Component State to Redux

Redux data flow diagaram

In Redux everything begins by calling the createStore function, passing a reducer, the initial state, and then applyMiddleware(thunk), which in this case allows us to use the thunk middleware to handle asynchronous code.

import { createStore, applyMiddleware } from "redux";
import thunk from "redux-thunk";

import reducer from "./reducer";

default createStore(
reducer,
{
term: "",
images: [],
status: "initial"
},
applyMiddleware(thunk)
);

Our reducer modifies the state, based on the data coming when actions are dispatched to it. We want to take a copy of our state, and then modify it based on the action's type:

export default (state = {}, action) => {
switch (action.type) {
case "BEGIN_SEARCH":
return {
...state,
term: action.term,
images: [],
status: "searching"
};
case "DONE_SEARCH":
return {
...state,
images: action.images,
status: "done"
};
case "ERROR_SEARCH":
return {
...state,
status: "error"
};
default:
return state;
}
};

The reducer is called when an action creator (function) dispatches an action (an object). In our case, we had to return a function which receives dispatch, because we are dealing with asynchronous code (handled by thunk).

import axios from "axios";

const fetchImages = term => {
return async dispatch => {
dispatch({
type: "BEGIN_SEARCH",
term
});

try {
const response = await axios.get(
"https://api.unsplash.com/search/photos",
{
params: {
client_id: "abcdefg",
query: term
}
}
);
dispatch({
type: "DONE_SEARCH",
images: response.data.results
});
} catch (error) {
dispatch({
type: "ERROR_SEARCH"
});
}
};
};

{ fetchImages };

Connecting Redux to React

To connect our Redux store to React we need to use the connect function. But before we can do that, we must first wrap our top level component in a Provider.

import { Provider } from "react-redux";
import store from "./store";

ReactDOM.render(
<Provider store={store}>
<App />
</Provider>,
document.getElementById("root")
);

Connect wants 2 functions, typically called mapStateToProps and mapDispatchToProps. This allows us to pass state into our component, and action creators which can dispatch actions to the reducer which will modify the state.

const mapStateToProps = state => {
return {
term: state.term,
images: state.images,
status: state.status
};
};

const mapDispatchToProps = dispatch => {
return {
fetchImages: term => {
dispatch(fetchImages(term));
}
};
};

default connect(
mapStateToProps,
mapDispatchToProps
)(App);

Conclusion

I hope you enjoyed a comparison between MobX and Redux! Redux is the most popular state management tool out there, but MobX is what I enjoy most... maybe because in my heart of hearts I like the "style" of object-oriented programming? Either way they are both great libraries and it's good to know what their differences are!